Very last play of the game......
- Jonathan S.
- God of Smack Talk
- Posts: 2955
- Joined: Wed Apr 30, 2003 8:13 am
- Name: Jonathan Smallwood
- MTFFL: Sheffield Feagle Eagles *1999,2002,2003,2006,2021*
- MTFFL II: Gainesboro by Gods *2006*
- Location: Up in the UC
- Jonathan S.
- God of Smack Talk
- Posts: 2955
- Joined: Wed Apr 30, 2003 8:13 am
- Name: Jonathan Smallwood
- MTFFL: Sheffield Feagle Eagles *1999,2002,2003,2006,2021*
- MTFFL II: Gainesboro by Gods *2006*
- Location: Up in the UC
- the Man, the Myth...
- Smack Talking Beast
- Posts: 643
- Joined: Mon May 17, 2004 12:23 pm
- Name: John Flatt
- MTFFL: Putnam Punishers *2012, 2013, 2016*
- MTFFL II: Smyrna Havoc *2011, 2012*
- Location: Murfreesboro,TN
-
The Guru
- Smack Talking Beast
- Posts: 719
- Joined: Sat May 31, 2003 4:29 pm
- Name: Shane Eldridge
- MTFFL: Riverboat Gamblers *2014*
- MTFFL II: Las Vegas Gamblers
- Location: Las Vegas
Nice formula on your aurgument for proportional adjustments and I agree. So why then are TD's the same for real and fantasy league?
My earlier post stated that TD's in fantasy should be approximitly around 18 to 22 if we stick to our proportional argument, and that seems the case then 7 pt HFA wouldnt be anything to get uptight about, but since it is more than a TD its crazy. To say a field is worth more than a TD in the NFL would be as one great man put it..." perposterous". 7HFA pts out of a 20 pt td is 35% of the TD- no big deal.. But 7 HFA pts out of a 6 pt td is 1.16% of the TD meaning obviously it doesnt even cover it.
Answer the qustion Commish your on the High LIfe hotsit and we can handle the truth, so lets hear hear it.
I dont want to seem like I am ganging up on the Commish because as we all know he does a Great job and I would be the first to buy him a bear but the logic isnt adding up.
If it is maybe you or someone else can help me understand.
My earlier post stated that TD's in fantasy should be approximitly around 18 to 22 if we stick to our proportional argument, and that seems the case then 7 pt HFA wouldnt be anything to get uptight about, but since it is more than a TD its crazy. To say a field is worth more than a TD in the NFL would be as one great man put it..." perposterous". 7HFA pts out of a 20 pt td is 35% of the TD- no big deal.. But 7 HFA pts out of a 6 pt td is 1.16% of the TD meaning obviously it doesnt even cover it.
Answer the qustion Commish your on the High LIfe hotsit and we can handle the truth, so lets hear hear it.
I dont want to seem like I am ganging up on the Commish because as we all know he does a Great job and I would be the first to buy him a bear but the logic isnt adding up.
If it is maybe you or someone else can help me understand.
- woody
- Smack Room Regular
- Posts: 247
- Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2004 12:31 pm
- Name: Jason Woody
- MTFFL: Nashville Knuckledraggers
- Location: I'm right here man
First, let me say that I truly appreciate all the time and effort that Jeff puts in to making the MTFFL the best fantasy league out there, bar none. (I'm hoisting a glass of beer for the Commish. Okay, not really, I'm at work, but I will at the Preds game tonight!) Also, I am all for keeping the rules that distinguish ours from other leagues in place.
I don't feel as if anything I said has been taken out of context or distorted. However, I think that something might have been misunderstood. For the record, I am 100% against turning this into a TD/FG/XP only league.
I think there are several good points in this thread, and truthfully, despite my wish to see it reduced, it won't bother me if HFA stays where it is. As much as I enjoy a healthy argument, message boards are tricky places to do that because sarcasm just doesn't come across. Maybe instead we could all get together and discuss it over a few bottles of cheap vodka? I feel that is clearly the only solution. (Please note intended sarcasm)
Again, cheers to Jeff for his dedication!
I don't feel as if anything I said has been taken out of context or distorted. However, I think that something might have been misunderstood. For the record, I am 100% against turning this into a TD/FG/XP only league.
I think there are several good points in this thread, and truthfully, despite my wish to see it reduced, it won't bother me if HFA stays where it is. As much as I enjoy a healthy argument, message boards are tricky places to do that because sarcasm just doesn't come across. Maybe instead we could all get together and discuss it over a few bottles of cheap vodka? I feel that is clearly the only solution. (Please note intended sarcasm)
Again, cheers to Jeff for his dedication!
Cover it with gas and set it on fire!
- the Man, the Myth...
- Smack Talking Beast
- Posts: 643
- Joined: Mon May 17, 2004 12:23 pm
- Name: John Flatt
- MTFFL: Putnam Punishers *2012, 2013, 2016*
- MTFFL II: Smyrna Havoc *2011, 2012*
- Location: Murfreesboro,TN